MacRostie’s Merlots can sometimes seem like an afterthought, but they’re generally good and sound, and so it is with the ’05. Made mainly from the well-regarded Las Amigas vineyard in Carneros, it’s dry, fairly tannic and rather oaky, and shows currant, anise, cocoa and cedar flavors. ——S.H.(12/15/2008)—— 87

From the Napa side, a fine Merlot that shows why Carneros has such a well-deserved reputation for the variety. Dark and juicy, with plum, coffee and herb flavors, this wine has rich tannins and is very dry. It wil likely improve over the next five years.——S.H.(10/1/2004)—— 90

An improvement over the previous vintage, but also $5 more expensive. Nice notes of cola and plums on the nose. Shifts nicely from the palate to the finish. Solid, but a little tannic. Verve and lively acidity are in its favor. 2,000 cases made.——M.S.(6/1/1999)—— 87