A strange, earthy, it not slightly dirty effort, the 2013 Costieres de Nimes Vin Gourmand Rose has some good fruit, but just doesn't come together and shows more funk on the palate as well. There's better wines out there. www.dauvergne-ranvier.com Importer: The Sorting Table, Napa, CA; tel. (707) 603-1460

This is a medium-bodied, fresh and fruit-driven example of rose. The berry, peach and lime flavors make for uncomplicated fun and refreshment. Drink this blend of Grenache and Cinsault over the next few months.——J.C.(12/15/2011)—— 88