The nutty, smoky notes on the nose are overshadowed by taut, high-octane alcohol-mineral scents. The stony, mineral-laden palate also shows earthy, apple-oatmeal flavors. The mouthfeel is full, yet tight (we could say ripe, but it’s not fruit-driven wine). This unusual offering fades long but closed, with hints of spice and coffee. Previous tastings of Mt. Carmel have proved it a tough read when young. Hold and taste in three years.——W.E.(7/1/2001)—— 86

The fruit’s from a vineyard formerly owned by a Carmelite monastery, hence the name. This is a finely-structured Chardonnay to lay away for a few years. Angular and very tightly wound now, but deep and complex. It will reward the faithful who cellar it.——W.E.(11/15/1999)—— 92