The 1995 Cabernet Sauvignon Stags Leap Vineyard reveals more fruit and depth than the Fay Vineyard, but it comes across as a restrained, excessively subtle, round, crisp, edgy sort of wine with fine fruit, but overbearing acidity. (Tasted in barrel.)
Stags Leap Wine Cellars' red wines have always been among my favorites, but I was surprised by the pronounced level of tart acidity found in the 1995s. High acidity, together with a low PH, causes a wine's texture to become compressed. The result is a wine that tastes too compact and lean. The 1995s possess excellent to outstanding raw materials, but does this vintage (the 1994s are also high in acidity) signal a change in the winemaking philosophy at Stag's Leap? I hope not.
Tel. (707) 944-2020